| |
|
Osteoporosis quick look
|
|
This chart rates treatment options according to general effectiveness, ease of use,
side effects and safety.
|
Vitamin D
|

Very good
|
|
|
|
|
|
Very effective. Safe and convenient. Recommended for all women to prevent osteoporosis. All women should get the right amount of vitamin D either through exposure to sunlight, diet (many products such as milk are fortified with vitamin D) or by taking vitamin D, usually in the form of a multivitamin.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Vitamin D
Like calcium, an adequate amount of vitamin D is necessary for bone health and to prevent bone loss. Most (80-95%) of our vitamin D is produced by the skin when it is exposed to sunlight; or it is consumed in vitamin D enriched foods. Many women do not get enough vitamin D, especially if they do not get out in the sun regularly, or live in parts of the country with less sunlight. The body's ability to manufacture vitamin D naturally decreases with age and older individuals are more prone to vitamin D deficiency. In addition, sunscreen interferes with vitamin D production and because of this, many dermatologists recommend vitamin D supplements for people who routinely use sunscreen.
Vitamin D deficiency is very common. More than half of older women in the U.S. are vitamin D deficient; and more than a third of younger women are as well. The easiest way to get enough vitamin D is to take a single multivitamin every day. Each multivitamin has 400 units of vitamin D. Women should take 400 to 800 units a day (1 or 2 multivitamins). No one should take 2000 or more units per day since this can be toxic (poisonous).
|
|
|
|
Calcium
(Tums, Tums EX, Tums Ultra, Tums 500, Caltrate 600, Viactiv, Calcium carbonate; Os-Cal 500, Citracal, calcium citrate, more)
|

Very good
|
|
|
|
|
|
Adequate calcium intake recommended for all women to prevent osteoporosis, and particulary for women with osteoporosis because it helps to decrease bone thinning. Sufficient daily calcium can be achieved either through the diet or through calcium supplements.
Safe, effective and relatively convenient. Many women who do not get enough calcium in their diet will need to take calcium supplements
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Calcium
The effectiveness of calcium for preventing bone thinning has not been well-studied, but is widely believed to help. According to the National Academy of Sciences guidelines, women from ages 19 to menopause should get 1000 mg per day of calcium and, after menopause, 1200 mg per day. In contrast, the Foods Standard Industry guidelines in Britain recommends 700 mg per day. Optimal daily amounts have not been firmly established. The body can only absorb about 600 mg at a time, so calcium supplements should be taken twice a day.
Foods high in calcium are: - Sardines with bones (4 oz=496 mg)
- nonfat yogurt (8 oz=452 mg)
- collard greens (1 cup=350mg)
- orange juice (1 cup=350mg)
- canned sardines (6 oz=333 mg)
- instant oatmeal (2 packages=326mg)
- 1%-2%-skim-whole milk (1 cup=300 mg)
- cheese (1 oz=250 mg)
- ice cream (1 cup=160 mg)
- almonds (half cup=152 mg)
- okra (1 cup=147 mg)
- vegetarian baked beans (1 cup=128mg)
- cottage cheese (1 cup=125mg)
- broccoli (1 cup=100 mg).
Other foods high in calcium include dark green leafy vegetables such as bok choy, kale and spinach; canned salmon (with bones); tofu and soy products; oats; and foods fortified with calcium such as cereals, orange juice and breads.
Most women do not get enough calcium from their diet alone. In addition, the body's ability to absorb calcium from food decreases with age and older women are more at risk of inadequate calcium intake. The cost of a month's supply of 1200 mg/day of calcium supplements range from $2.99 to $15.98. Regular Tums costs between $2.99 and $5.99 a month; each chewable tablet has 200 mg.
Viactiv costs $15.98 a month but it has 500 mg of calcium per chew and also has vitamin D in it. Recent studies emphasize the importance of combining vitamin D and calcium, but taking them in the same pill is more a matter of convenience.
|
|
|
|
Weight-bearing exercise
(Walking briskly, jogging, stair climbing, dancing, tennis, etc.)
|

Very good
|
|
|
|
|
|
Very effective. Recommended for all women to prevent osteoporosis, and for women with osteoporosis to decrease bone thinning. All women with osteoporosis should perform weight-bearing exercise for 30 minutes three times per week. Safe, when done in a controlled or supervised exercise program.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Weight-bearing exercise
Weight-bearing exercise helps to stop bone loss. Walking briskly, jogging, stair climbing, dancing, and tennis are all examples of weight-bearing exercise which should be done for at least 30 minutes at a time, three or more times a week. Swimming or cycling are NOT weight-bearing. Weight-bearing exercise mostly benefits the lower body.
Lifting weights or using weight machines (weight or "resistance" training) also helps increase strength especially in the upper body, and improves balance (which prevents falls).
Engaging in these activities is not so easy for people who do not like to exercise but is very effective, not just for bone maintenance but for the health of many other body systems (heart, blood vessels, lungs, etc.) as regular exercise has many other benefits.
|
|
|
|
|
Avoidance of smoking and too much alcohol
|

Very good
|
|
|
|
|
|
Very safe and effective although not easy to do for many smokers. Particulary important for all women with osteoporosis, as both alcohol and tobacco smoke are bad for bone health.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Avoidance of smoking and too much alcohol
Even though the mechanism is not understood, smoking has been shown in studies to be an important risk factor for osteoporosis and weak bones.
Excess alcohol use interferes with the body's ability to absorb calcium and form bone. Too much alcohol intake is also a risk factor for falling, which increases the risk of broken bones (fractures) in people with osteoporosis.
Heavy alcohol consumption can also cause bone loss from poor nutrition. Many experts recommend no more than two alcoholic beverages per day.
|
|
|
|
Bone mineral density testing (BMD)
(DEXA Scan or Bone Densitometry)
|

Not available
|
|
|
|
|
Most accurate way to diagnose osteoporosis. Expensive. Uses small amount of radiation. Painless. Takes only a few minutes, but must be done at a center that has special equipment. DEXA of the hip is the best; examination of the heel bone with ultrasound is less accurate.
Tests are recommended for women over age 65 and for those with risk factors who are 65 or under.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Bone mineral density testing (BMD)
DEXA (dual energy X-ray absorptiometry) is a test that aims x-rays at a bone to see how much radiation passes through, allowing the calculation of the density or thickness or the bone. This test uses small amount of radiation (less than 1/10th the amount of radiation in a chest X-ray). It can measure the density of the hip, spine and forearm bones. Of all the bone density tests, DEXA is the most accurate. A single energy X-ray absorptiometry test measures the density of the heel and the forearm, and is not as good a predictor of significant fractures as the DEXA scan. An ultrasound can measure the density of the heel bone and is also not as accurate as DEXA. A CT scan (Computerized tomography) provides accurate measurements of the spine bones but involves high doses of radiation, is expensive, and is therefore seldom used.
DEXA results are reported in units called "T-scores" which compares a person's bone density to that of a healthy young adult of the same gender. The results of this test can be confusing: if the score is higher than -1 ("negative 1"), results are considered normal. (For example, "-0.5" and "+1" are both higher than -1; this is because of the negative sign). If the score is between -1 and -2.5, the diagnosis is osteopenia (early thinning of the bones that may lead to osteoporosis); and if below -2.5, osteoporosis is diagnosed. You may also be given a "Z-score", which compares your score to what would normally be expected for someone of your age, sex, weight, and ethinic or racial origin.
Guidelines vary somewhat about who should have a BMD test. Most guidelines recommend that women over the age of 65 be tested. They also tend to recommend that women younger than age 65 be tested if they have particular risk factors or have had a fracture that could be related to osteoporosis. Specific guidelines are as follows:
US Preventive Services Task Force: - Women over 65
- Women between 60 to 64 who weigh less than 154 pounds and are not using estrogen
American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists: - Women over 65
- Women over 40 who have had a fracture
- Women with risk factors for fracture who would consider treatment with medications
- Women with x-rays that suggest osteoporosis
- Women who are taking steroids or other medications that can cause significant bone loss
- Women with diseases or nutritional conditions associated with bone loss such as symptomatic "hyperparathyroidism"
North American Menopause Society: - Women over 65
- Women who have a medical condition that can cause bone loss
- Postmenopausal women below age 65 with one of the following risk factors: a fracture after menopause (other than of the spine); body weight less than 127 pounds; or a history of a first-degree relative (mother, sister, daughter, etc) who has had a hip or spine fracture
- Premenopausal women who experience a low-trauma fracture (broken bone that results from a minor or low-impact injury) or who have a condition that is known to cause osteoporosis
American College of Obstetricians and Gynechologists - Women over 65
- All postmenopausal women with fractures
- Possibly recommended for women with one or more risk factor for osteoporosis
|
|
|
|
Bisphosphonates
(Fosamax/alendronate, Actonel/risedronate, Boniva/ibandronate, Reclast/zoledronic acid)
|

Good
|
|
|
|
|
|
Recommended for both treatment and prevention of osteoporosis. Prevents both hip and spinal fractures. The first medications usually prescribed for osteoporosis. Availble by pill or by injection/intravenous. Pill must be taken on an empty stomach without eating or drinking for 30 minutes. Can cause significant problems with the swallowing tube (esophagus) and must be taken with 8 oz of water with the individual remaining upright for 30 minutes afterwards.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Bisphosphonates
Several large studies have been performed to evaluate the effectiveness of osteoporosis drugs. However, there have been no good studies that directly compare the different drugs to each other. Therefore, no one is certain which of the various medication options are most effective, but experts have formed certain opinions based on studies of individual drugs and on clinical experience with the medications.
Bisphosphonates (Fosamax, Actonel, Boniva, Reclast) appear to be the most effective medications available for decreasing the chance of fracturing either the spine, hip, or other bones. Several large studies have found that Fosamax (alendronate) increases bone density (the thickness of bones). The drug also decreases the risk of breaking the bones of the spine and hip by about around 50 percent. This translates into prevention of approximately 3 hip fractures a year for every 1,000 people who are taking the drug.
Studies suggest that Actonel (risedronate), another bisphosphonate, is also effective for decreasing broken bones. Boniva (ibandronate), the newest bisphosphonate, also increases bone density and decreases fractures. One large study suggests that Boniva may be effective if given once a month instead of daily or once a week. A powerful new bisphosphonate, Reclast (zoledronic acid), in one study decreased spine fractures by 70% and hip fractures by 41%. This drug, however,has to be given through an IV (intravenous needle) and is not used to prevent osteoporosis; only to treat it once it occurs.
An individual on a bisphosphonate probably needs to stay on the medication indefinately since the effect of is drug may wear off slowly over time. But since this takes a while to happen, some experts think that it may be possible to stop the drug for a while ("drug holiday") and then start again on a cycle of some sort; however, this hasn't been studied yet.
Alendronate (Fosamax) is available in daily and weekly doses; risedronate (Actonel) is available in daily, weekly and twice monthly doses; ibandronate (Boniva) is available as a monthly dose and as an intravenous injection once every three months; zoledronic acid (Reclast) is given once a year as an intravenous injection.
The pill-form of bisphosphonates are not absorbed well, which is why the stomach has to be empty and stay empty for a while after taking a dose. Pills must be taken on an empty stomach without eating or drinking anything else including other pills for 30 minutes. The pills can also cause significant irritation of the swallowing tube (esophagus) and must be taken with 8 oz of water with the individual remaining upright or sitting for 30 minutes afterwards. The intravenous form of the drug may be recommended for people who have side effects with pills.
Side effects with the pills include digestive tract problems that can be severe such as trouble swallowing, inflammation of the esophagus (swallowing tube that connects the mouth to the stomach), and esophagus and stomach ulcers. There have also been rare instances of vision problems and damage to the jaw bone (typically after trauma from a tooth extraction or cancer treatment, for example). Because of this, experts recommend informing dentists that you are taking a bisphosphonate before a tooth extraction. Intravenous injections have been reported to cause flu-like symptoms such as fever, muscle and joint aches and headache that typically last for a few days.
People with a history of problems with the swallowing tube (esophagus) should not take bisphosphonates.
|
|
|
|
Evista/raloxifene
(Selective Estrogen Receptor Modulator)
|

Fair
|
|
|
|
|
|
Recommended for both treatment and prevention of osteoporosis. Works like estrogen but does not have some of the risks of estrogen. While it seems to be about as good as alendronate in decreasing fractures of the spine (but not hip), it is not usually chosen first because of side effects. Commonly causes hot flashes. Not for use in men with osteoporosis.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Evista/raloxifene
Raloxifene/Evista (an estrogen-like drug) is related to tamoxifen that is used to treat breast cancer in older women. This type of drug may have the advantage of estrogen and "hormone replacement therapy" in decreasing bone thinning and the risk of fractures, but without increasing the risk of breast cancer. In one study, raloxifene decreased the number of repeat spine fractures by 30 percent in postmenopausal women who had already had a fracture; and by about half in women who had never had one. However, in contrast to estrogen, raloxifen is not effective for hot flashes or urinary symptoms that are often a part of menopause.
The biggest risk in taking raloxifene is of developing blood clots (just like with estrogen), and it should not be used in women who have had blood clots previously. The medication can cause hot flashes and leg cramps.
This drug mimics the effects of female hormones and is not approved for use in men with osteoporosis.
Several large studies have been performed to evaluate the effectiveness of osteoporosis drugs. However, there have been no good studies that directly compare the different drugs to each other. Therefore, no one is certain which of the various medication options are most effective, but experts have formed certain opinions based on clinical experience with the medications.
|
|
|
|
|
Miacalcin/calcitonin
|

Fair
|
|
|
|
|
|
Used in women who have had menopause for at least five years and have osteoporosis that has not improved with other medications. Not for osteoporosis prevention. Not considered as effective as bisphosphonates (Fosamax, Actonel, Boniva). Prevents spinal fractures but may not be as effective for hip fractures. Usually prescribed for people who cannot use other drugs. May have an added benefit of reducing the pain of a new fracture. Typically used as a nasal spray. Can cause nasal irritation.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Miacalcin/calcitonin
Calcitonin seems to work on bones of the spine but may not work as well for hip bones. Since hip fractures are a common problem for women with osteoporosis, calcitonin may not be as useful as the bisphosphonates. One study showed that spine fractures were decreased by 33 percent after two years of taking the medicine.
Calcitonin is sprayed into the nose. Each spray gives 200 Units of the drug; the usual dose is one spray per day (one day in one nostril, and the next day in the other). Up to 400 Units per day can be given for severe osteoporosis which would be one spray in each nostril every day. Calcitonin is also available as an injection.
Calcitonin prevents bone thinning by slowing down the cells that naturally destroy/recycle bone.
Several large studies have been performed to evaluate the effectiveness of osteoporosis drugs. However, there have been no good studies that directly compare the different drugs to each other. Therefore, no one is certain which of the various medication options are most effective, but experts have formed certain opinions based on clinical experience with the medications.
Calcitonin is usually used in women who have had menopause for at least five years and have osteoporosis that has not improved with other medications.
Calcitonin is not available as a pill but is used as a nasal spray or can be injected. It may have an added benefit of reducing the pain of a new fracture which may be especially helpful for people with a new spine fracture. It can cause stuffiness of the nose and upset of the stomach and bowels.
|
|
|
|
Estrogen containing drugs/Hormone treatment
(Hormone Replacement Therapy/"HRT")
|

Poor
|
|
|
|
|
|
Estrogen-containing drugs are sometimes used for osteoporosis prevention; no longer routinely recommended for osteoporosis treatment.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Estrogen containing drugs/Hormone treatment
Estrogen (hormone replacement therapy) used to be the primary treatment for osteoporosis prevention but is no longer the drug of choice because of safety concerns (blood clots, stroke, breast cancer) and because of the availability of alternative medications that are considered safer.
Studies have shown that estrogen is effective in increasing bone density (bone thickness) and in decreasing fractures in both the spine and hip. Estrogen hormone acts directly on bone to decrease thinning.
Estrogen-containing hormone replacement therapy is most often used currently to treat severe symptoms of menopause that are not alleviated with other measures.
|
|
|
|
Forteo/teriparatide/
(Recombinant parathyroid hormone)
|

Good
|
|
|
|
|
Newer drug. Very effective. Many potential side effects. Given once-a-day by injection. Usually used only for postmenopausal women who have a very high risk for fractures, or in men with osteoporosis. Only drug that actually helps form new bone instead of just preventing bone loss.
Long-term effects need further study. Only approved for use for two years or less.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Forteo/teriparatide/
Teriparatide works by stimulating new bone formation rather than decreasing bone loss, which makes it different from the other drugs used for osteoporosis. This drug is available as a once-a-day injection given under the skin. It is usually only used for postmenopausal women who have a high risk for fractures, and is also approved for men with osteoporosis.
The drug causes bone cancer (osteosarcomas) in animals and should NOT be used in children or adolescents. It also should not be used in individuals with high calcium in the blood since it can further increase calcium levels.
Studies in postmenopausal women and men with osteoporosis treated for about a year with teriparatide along with calcium and vitamin D supplements showed increases in bone density in the spine and hip. The drug cannot be given all of the time, without a break, or it can cause bone loss. When given at regular intervals (in pulses) teriparatide increased bone density by 15% over 3 years, compared to a 6 to 8% increase for alendronate (Fosamax). In these studies, the drug decreased spine fractures as well as other fractures.
Side effects can include nausea, dizziness and leg cramps. Because long-term effects and safety have not yet been studied, teriparatide has only been approved for use by the US FDA (Food and Drug Administration) for up to 24 months.
|
|
|
|
Osteoporosis-prevention/treatment for people taking steroid medications
(Prednisone, dexamethasone, many others)
|

Not available
|
|
|
|
|
|
Long-term steroid use significantly increases the risk of bone loss/osteoporosis. Guidelines recommend measures to prevent bone loss for individuals on steroid medications for more than 6 weeks.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Osteoporosis-prevention/treatment for people taking steroid medications
Many people have medical conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis, ulcerative colitis, lupus, asthma and other lung disease, etc. that require long-term use of "steroid" medications (prednisone, dexamethasone, etc). While these medicines are often life-saving, one of their side effects is thinning of the bones. The risk of fractures is 30% greater if taking steroids.
Preventing this bone thinning is best accomplished with weight-bearing exercise and supplements of calcium and vitamin D. Many people will need osteoporosis medications as well. Bisphosphonates are most commonly used, but special situations may require other osteoporosis medications such as calcitonin, female hormone replacement therapy, or Raloxifene, based on the particular situation.
Most experts feel that a baseline study of bone density (BMD test) should be performed when starting a long-term (more than 6 weeks) course of steroids, and then should be repeated every two years.
|
|
|
|
|
Osteoporosis-prevention for certain people receiving cancer chemotherapy or who have cancer in the bones
|

Not available
|
|
|
|
|
|
Bone loss can occur with many kinds of chemotherapies, as well as in those who have cancer that spreads to the bones (most commonly with breast and prostate cancers). Early treatment to prevent osteoporosis is recommended by many experts.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Osteoporosis-prevention for certain people receiving cancer chemotherapy or who have cancer in the bones
Early treatment is essential to prevent fractures. It is best to optimize calcium and vitamin D intake, exercise regularly if possible, quit smoking, and eat nutritiously. Many people will need supplemental treatment with oral or intravenous bisphosphonates, Raloxifene or female hormone replacement therapy, depending on their primary condition.
|
|
|
|
Soy-containing foods and supplements
(Phytoestrogens)
|

Poor
|
|
|
|
|
|
Not recommended. There is no evidence to suggest that soy-containing foods or supplements have any effect on bone loss.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Soy-containing foods and supplements
Soy foods contain an estrogen/female hormone-like substance called "phytoestrogen" and have been used as home remedies for menopause symptoms. There is no evidence, however, that soy-containg foods prevent osteoporosis, or decrease the risk of bone fracture.
The North American Menopause Society (NAMS) guidelines consider soy-containing products/foods to be not harmful, except for certain women (who should also not receive supplemental female hormones/estrogen) including women who have a personal or strong family history of: - breast, uterine, or ovarian cancer;
- blood clots;
- endometriosis;
- or uterine fibroids.
These women, who should not take estrogen, also should not take large amounts of soy or isoflavones.
|
|
|
|
|
Low dose estrogen
|

Not available
|
|
|
|
|
|
Under investigation to evaluate whether low dose estrogen is as effective as higher doses for preventing osteoporosis and whether or not lower doses are safer than conventional doses.
Tell Me More...
|
|
| |

Low dose estrogen
One study suggested that low doses of estrogen (either with or without progestin) may be effective for osteoporosis prevention but data is still inconclusive and more study is necessary. In this study, doses that were approximately half (0.3-0.45 mg per day) of that normally prescribed reduced bone loss in women who had recently gone through menopause. Further evaluation is necessary to determine if these finding are reproducible and therefore reliable.
In addition, experts hope that lower dose estrogen does not present the same safety problems as the higher doses (increased risk of stroke, blood clots, and breast cancer) but this question has not been adequately addressed and for now, it is safer to assume that the risks do not differ until proven otherwise.
|
|
|
|
|
|