My Drugs & SymptomsDrugsDrugs By ConditionTreatments
  Drug Search

   
 
Low Back Pain quick look
This chart rates treatment options according to general effectiveness, ease of use, side effects and safety.
Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Early Phase Pain (up to 4-6 wks) - Recommended
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Early return to light, non-strenuous activities  

Very good 
 
 
 
 
Effective. Early return to light activities improves recovery. Bed rest discouraged - prolongs symptoms. Check with your physician for an activity plan that is appropriate for your situation.

Heavy or strenuous activity, as well as bending and twisting should be avoided (see Activity Modification below).
Tell Me More...
  Close

Early return to light, non-strenuous activities

In studies, those who resumed normal, non-strenuous activities recovered sooner than did those who rested in bed or people who did more intense back strengthening exercises right away.

Experts recommend that back pain-sufferers resume light daily activities as soon as possible. Exercise such as walking typically can be resumed after the first day or two. People with intolerable symptoms may need to take it easier for longer but bed rest is discouraged, in general, for longer than 1-2 days.

Individuals with low back pain used to be treated with bed rest. However, studies have shown that people who went back to ordinary activities recovered sooner than those who rested in bed or who did vigorous back strengthening exercises.

All well-designed studies addressing this issue have reached similar conclusions: that people with low back pain who remain active and involved in ordinary, light activities:

  • Experience less long-term disability
  • Return to work faster
  • Require fewer health care visits, tests, and procedures

None of the studies found that bed rest improved the chance of recovery. None of the studies found that early return to light activities had any harmful effects.

 
Education
(Back classes; programs that encourage early return to light, ordinary activity)
 

Very good 
 
 
 
 
The best means of avoiding future episodes is to use proper lifting techniques, maintain a healthy weight, and stop smoking.

New evidence suggests that recovery from episodes of back pain can be improved through programs that educate back pain-sufferers about the safety and advantages of resuming light, ordinary activity.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Education

Ninety per cent of people with back pain recover in a few weeks. Most recover within two weeks. Half have recurring pain in the next year. Studies have suggested that the best means of avoiding future episodes is to use proper lifting techniques, maintain a healthy weight, and stop smoking. Classes in back care have been very helpful for prevention of future problems.

A well-designed five year study of more than 500 back pain sufferers looked at education and reassurance that ordinary, light activity is safe and improves the chance of recovery (Klenerman, Slade; 1995). The study found that people who received this information were much more likely to recover and return to a normal lifestyle than people who did not receive education.

Patients in the study who received education were told that:

  • Their low back pain may be caused by a crack in a disc ("cushion") that sits between the bones of the spine that can lead to irritation and swelling;
  • The irritation causes spasm (tightening) and stiffness in the nearby muscles that support the back. The tension and high pressure can decrease the flow of blood to these muscles which causes more pain;
  • The pain due to muscle spasm causes the back to tense even more, creating a cycle which further increases pain;
  • Fear also causes the back muscles to tense even more, which maintains the cycle of increased spasm, pain, and decreased blood flow to muscles;
  • The worst thing that a person with back pain can do is to be too cautious and, as a result, tense up his or her back

To improve their condition, people were told:

  • That light activity would not worsen their condition and would not further injure the disc ("cushion"). Instead activity could relax the muscles, improve blood flow which helps with healing;
  • To walk as normally and as flexibly as possible (without tensing muscles)
  • To avoid activities in which the back is rigid or tense for long periods of time
  • To treat attacks of low back pain with light stretching and light activity
  • To lift objects using the muscles of the legs and thighs more than the back, and to avoid twisting the back while it is bent

No exercise goals were set, but people were encouraged to set their own exercise goals after speaking with their physicians. The educational messages were repeated at three months and, again, at one year.

More...
The study found that 60% of the patients who did not receive education were still out of work after 200 days compared to 30% of the patients who received education. After five years, 34% of the group who did not get education were still out on sick leave compared to 19% of the group who had the education.
REFERENCES
  • Agency for Health Care Policy and Research. Acute Low Back Pain in Adults: Assessment and Treatment. Rockville: US Department of Health and Human Services. 1994. Royal College of General Practitioners, Chartered Society of Physiotherapy, Osteopathic Association of Great Britain, British Chiropractic Association, National Back Pain Association. Clinical Guidelines for the Management of Acute Low Back Pain. London: Royal College of General Practitioners, 1996.
  • National Advisory Committee on Core health and Disability Services, Accident Rehabilitation and Compensation Insurance Corporation. Clinical Practice Guidelines. Acute Low Back Problems in Adults: Assessment and Treatment. Wellington: Core Services Committee, Ministry of Health (New Zealand), 1995.
  • Quality of Care and Health Outcomes Committee. Guidelines for the development and implementation of clinical practice guidelines. Canberra: National Health and Medical Research Councils, 1995.
  • National Health and Medical Research Councils. A guide to the development, implementation and evaluation of clinical practice guidelines. Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra, 1999.
  • American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Evidence-based recommendations for patients with acute activity intolerance due to low back symptoms. Orthopaedic Update 1995; 5: 625-632.
  • American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons and North American Spine Society. Draft Clinical Algorithm on Low back Pain. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons and North American

 
Activity Modification  

Very good 
 
 
 
 
Limiting activities to those that do not strain the back is recommended.

More than two days of bed rest is not recommended unless pain is extreme.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Activity Modification

Studies suggest that bed rest for longer than 1-2 days does not improve back pain and may, in fact, prolong symptoms. Experts recommend that people with low back pain continue day-to-day activities within the limits permitted by pain. Exercises such as weight lifting that strain the back should be avoided during the first 4-6 weeks of pain. Exercises such as walking and swimming are better choices. Most experts recommend that prolonged sitting (especially with the back unsupported), heavy lifting, and bending/twisting while lifting are strictly avoided.

 
Tylenol/acetaminophen, many others  

Good 
 
 
 
 
Tylenol (acetaminophen) is safe and effective if used during the first few weeks of low back symptoms.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Tylenol/acetaminophen, many others

Tylenol is effective for pain control for people with low back pain. There is no conclusive evidence about whether or not pain control decreases the duration of the back pain episode.

 
Anti-inflammatory Drugs
(Aleve/naproxen, Motrin or Advil/ibuprofen, aspirin, more)
 

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Effective for pain control. Recommended for use during the early phase (first few weeks) of back pain, but can cause significant side effects with daily use.

There is no conclusive evidence that use of these medications will decrease the duration of the back pain episode.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Anti-inflammatory Drugs

Guidelines/experts suggest that anti-inflammatory medications be used on a regular schedule (roughly every 6-8 hours) for the first few weeks of a back pain bout rather than on an "as-needed" basis to keep the pain (and inflammation) at an acceptable level. These drugs can cause significant side effects, however, such as stomach pain and bleeding ulcers when taken daily and should be used with caution, especially in older individuals who are much more susceptible to developing side effects. They are safer if they are taken with milk or food.

These drugs should generally not be used in those who have kidney problems or are pregnant. People who also have high blood pressure may need to take these medications cautiously.

 
Local Cold/Heat Application
(Ice bags, heating pads, etc.)
 

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Limited evidence about effectiveness. Recommended by many experts.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Local Cold/Heat Application

Cold packs applied to the sore area for the first 2 days may decrease pain and spasm. Inexpensive gel packs are more convenient and less messy than ice. After the first 2 days, switching to heat, particularly moist heat, along with light massage and warm baths may help symptoms. There is no objective evidence that either heat or cold will decrease the overall length of the back pain episode, even though they may provide temporary relief of symptoms.

 
Muscle Relaxants
(Flexeril/cyclobenzaprine, Soma/carisoprodol, Robaxin/methocarbamol, Valium/diazepam, many others)
 

Poor 
 
 
 
 
Muscle relaxants are sometimes helpful for the first few days after injury but can cause drowsiness and other side effects. There is no evidence that they have any usefulness for people who have chronic (long-standing) back problems.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Muscle Relaxants

There is some evidence that muscle relaxants provide short-term symptom relief but no evidence that, when combined with anti-inflammatory medications, the combination is any better than either one by itself. Anti-inflammatory medications remain the preferred choice of treatment, because they cause fewer side effects, are available without a prescription, and are relatively inexpensive.

 
Opioid Analgesics
(Narcotics)
 

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
No more effective for pain relief than safer alternatives. Only recommended if pain is severe and if other non-narcotic pain drugs fail to adequately control symptoms. Safety problems.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Opioid Analgesics

Narcotics have not been found to be more effective than safer drugs such as Tylenol (acetaminophen) or anti-inflammatory drugs (Motrin, Advil, Aleve, more) in relieving low back pain symptoms. Narcotics can sometimes be used for severe symptoms, but the risk of complications such as drowsiness, depression, and addiction must be carefully considered.

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Early Phase Pain (up to 4-6 wks) - Other Options
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Massage  

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Limited evidence. May be helpful.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Massage

A few studies have shown promising results for early phase low back pain treatment. More study data is necessary for conclusive recommendations.

 
Shoe insoles and shoe lifts  

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Limited evidence. May be helpful for individuals who need to stand for long periods of time.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Shoe insoles and shoe lifts

Shoe insoles may be effective for individuals with low back pain symptoms who stand for prolonged periods. Given the low cost and low potential for ill effects, shoe insoles are sometimes recommended as a treatment option.

 
Spinal Manipulation
(Chiropractic treatment)
 

Poor 
 
 
 
 
Limited evidence that this treatment may be helpful during the early phase of low back pain (first 4-6 weeks). No evidence of effectiveness for chronic pain, however.

Should not be used if a pinched nerve is suspected (if pain radiates into the legs; if there is decreased sensation; muscle weakness; or trouble with bowel or bladder control).
Tell Me More...
  Close

Spinal Manipulation

Several small studies have suggested that spinal manipulation (chiropractic care) may be helpful for early phase low back pain (first 4 to 6 weeks).

In one small study, individuals who had spinal manipulation used slightly less medication than those who did not. Further study is necessary to draw reliable conclusions.

When a pinched nerve is suspected, however, further tests should be carried out before proceeding with manipulation/chiropractic treatment since spinal manipulation could cause nerve damage in this situation.

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Early Phase Pain (up to 4-6 wks) - Not Recommended
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Injection Therapy  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Injections of medication in the back are not recommended during the early phase of low back pain except for very rare and unusual cases.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Injection Therapy

Innections are more commonly used for people who have long-standing (chronic) back problems.

 
Physical therapy/Back Exercises  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Not effective for the early phase of low back pain (first 4-6 weeks).
Tell Me More...
  Close

Physical therapy/Back Exercises

Physical therapy/back exercises have not been proven effective for relief of early/acute symptoms, although they may be useful for chronic symptoms and to prevent recurrence.

 
Acupuncture  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Available evidence does not show effectiveness for early phase low back pain.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Acupuncture

Reviews of the medical literature have found insufficient evidence to support acupuncture as an effective method for treating early/acute low back pain. The studies that have been done are of poor quality.

There is some evidence to suggest that acupuncture may be helpful for some people who have longstanding (chronic) low back pain.

 
Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation
("TENS" unit)
 

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Not effective for early phase back pain (first 4-6 weeks).
Tell Me More...
  Close

Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation

With TENS treatment, a small electrical stimulation is delivered to the muscles of the low back for the purpose of decreasing pain. According to clinical studies, this procedure appears to be only rarely effective for longstanding back pain. There is no evidence to suggest, however, that it has any effect in treating early/acute back problems.

 
Lumbar Corsets and Back Belts  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Not effective for early/acute low back pain (first 4-6 weeks).
Tell Me More...
  Close

Lumbar Corsets and Back Belts

Corsets and belts have no proven benefit in early phase low back pain treatment. They are occasionally helpful for certain individuals who have longstanding (chronic) back problems.

 
Traction  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Traction involves stretching the spine with apparatus that is attached to the bed. Appears to be ineffective.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Traction

Studies have failed to show that traction is effective in acute or chronic low back pain treatment.

 
Biofeedback
(Mind/body training)
 

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
No evidence of effectiveness.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Biofeedback

Biofeedback has no proven benefit in early phase low back pain treatment.

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Early Phase Pain (up to 4-6 wks) - Special Situations
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Steroid Pills  

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Limited data. Sometimes prescribed for a few days for severe pain caused by a "pinched nerve" (disc herniation). Not recommended otherwise. Only for short-term pain relief. No evidence of an impact on long-term improvement. Not recommended for long-term use because of significant side effects.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Steroid Pills

The American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons, the North American Spine Society, the Institute for Systems Improvement (ICSI) and the Veterans Administration and Department of Defense have published guidelines on low back pain.

These guidelines recommend that a few days of steroid pills may be considered to reduce the nerve irritation when symptoms are severe or fail to improve in people with a "pinched nerve" (disc herniation).

Steroid pills are only effective for short-term pain relief; they do not improve long-term healing, and because of the potential for serious side effects, they are limited to short-term use for people with severe symptoms. They are not recommended for back strain only (when a "pinched nerve" is not present).

A "pinched" nerve (sciatica) is most commonly caused by pressure from a disc (or cushion) that sits between the bones of the spine. The disc can bulge out of place, or a piece can break off and press on a nearby nerve.

In most cases, a pinched nerve (sciatica) gets better without further treatment after a period of rest.

More...
Telling the difference between a simple back strain and a pinched nerve can be difficult . There are several clues that help your doctor tell them apart:
  • Pain from a pinched nerve usually travels below the knee (often down to the ankle) in very specific patterns, whereas pain from a muscle strain can travel to the upper leg but does not usually go below the knee
  • Pain and numbness from a pinched nerve is usually located in the specific part of the leg that the nerve runs along. The route that the affected nerve travels determines where the symptoms are felt. The exact path of a particular nerve can vary somewhat from individual to individual, but your doctor can get a pretty good sense, based on the location of your symptoms, whether or not the pattern suggests a pinched nerve
  • Typically, pain due to a pinched nerve travels to the lower leg in a narrow band that feels more like it is on the surface than deep in the leg. The pain from muscle sprains/strains is usually felt more deeply and in a wider band.

Diagnostic tests such as MRIs are helpful, but not conclusive in telling the two conditions apart. Studies have demonstrated that MRIs show herniated disc in 50% of healthy people without back symptoms. Just because a bulging disc is present on an MRI does not mean that it's the cause of the back pain. The diagnosis is generally made only when both symptoms and the MRI a consistent with a disc herniation.

With a herniated disc, the disc or "cushion" that sits between the bones of the spine develops a weakness/tear and begins to bulge. The bulging disc pinches the nerves of the spine as they travel to the legs (where they control sensation and movement). When a nerve is pinched, it can cause pain, numbness, or tingling in the legs. A back sprain/strain can also cause these leg symptoms but in different locations.

The reason it is important to tell a pinched nerve from simple muscle strain is that the two conditions are usually treated differently. For example, muscle strains are not generally treated with surgery, whereas a pinched nerve may be, usually as a last resort.

In summary, both muscle sprains and pinched nerves can cause pain, numbness, tingling, and loss of feeling in the leg - just in different locations. Pinched nerves can also cause muscle weakness in the legs, while simple muscle strains cannot.

If you have any doubts about your diagnosis, you may wish to get a second opinion from a back specialist (such as an orthopedist or neurosurgeon who specializes in low back problems).

......

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Chronic Pain - Recommended
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Education
(Back classes; programs that encourage early return to light, ordinary activity)
 

Very good 
 
 
 
 
New evidence suggests that recovery from episodes of back pain can be improved through programs that educate back pain-sufferers about the safety and advantages of engaging in light, ordinary activity and appropriate exercise programs.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Education

A well-designed five year study of more than 500 back pain sufferers looked at education and reassurance that ordinary, light activity is safe and improves the chance of recovery (Klenerman, Slade; 1995). The study found that people who received this information were much more likely to recover and return to a normal lifestyle than people who did not receive education.

Patients in the study who received education were told that:

  • Their low back pain may be caused by a crack in a disc ("cushion") that sits between the bones of the spine that can lead to irritation and swelling;
  • The irritation causes spasm (tightening) and stiffness in the nearby muscles that support the back. The tension and high pressure can decrease the flow of blood to these muscles which causes more pain;
  • The pain due to muscle spasm causes the back to tense even more, creating a cycle which further increases pain;
  • Fear also causes the back muscles to tense even more, which maintains the cycle of increased spasm, pain, and decreased blood flow to muscles;
  • The worst thing that a person with back pain can do is to be too cautious and, as a result, tense up his or her back

To improve their condition, people were told:

  • That light activity would not worsen their condition and would not further injure the disc ("cushion"). Instead activity could relax the muscles, improve blood flow which helps with healing;
  • To walk as normally and as flexibly as possible (without tensing muscles)
  • To avoid activities in which the back is rigid or tense for long periods of time
  • To treat attacks of low back pain with light stretching and light activity
  • To lift objects using the muscles of the legs and thighs more than the back, and to avoid twisting the back while it is bent

No exercise goals were set, but people were encouraged to set their own exercise goals after speaking with their physicians. The educational messages were repeated at three months and, again, at one year.

More...
The study found that 60% of the patients who did not receive education were still out of work after 200 days compared to 30% of the patients who received education. After five years, 34% of the group who did not get education were still out on sick leave compared to 19% of the group who had the education.
REFERENCES
  • Agency for Health Care Policy and Research. Acute Low Back Pain in Adults: Assessment and Treatment. Rockville: US Department of Health and Human Services. 1994. Royal College of General Practitioners, Chartered Society of Physiotherapy, Osteopathic Association of Great Britain, British Chiropractic Association, National Back Pain Association. Clinical Guidelines for the Management of Acute Low Back Pain. London: Royal College of General Practitioners, 1996.
  • National Advisory Committee on Core health and Disability Services, Accident Rehabilitation and Compensation Insurance Corporation. Clinical Practice Guidelines. Acute Low Back Problems in Adults: Assessment and Treatment. Wellington: Core Services Committee, Ministry of Health (New Zealand), 1995.
  • Quality of Care and Health Outcomes Committee. Guidelines for the development and implementation of clinical practice guidelines. Canberra: National Health and Medical Research Councils, 1995.
  • National Health and Medical Research Councils. A guide to the development, implementation and evaluation of clinical practice guidelines. Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra, 1999.
  • American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Evidence-based recommendations for patients with acute activity intolerance due to low back symptoms. Orthopaedic Update 1995; 5: 625-632.
  • American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons and North American Spine Society. Draft Clinical Algorithm on Low back Pain. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons and North American

 
Acetaminophen
(Tylenol, many others)
 

Good 
 
 
 
 
Tylenol (acetaminophen) is safe and effective when used to treat low back pain.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Acetaminophen

Tylenol is effective for pain control for individuals with low back pain. There is no conclusive evidence about whether or not pain control decreases the duration of the back pain, but it does help the user to stay comfortable.

 
Exercise  

Fair 
 
 
 
 
A careful exercise program can improve posture and strengthen the back. May shorten recovery and prevent future problems.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Exercise

Many experts and most guidelines recommend a back exercise program after 4-6 weeks. The goal of exercise is to increase conditioning and to learn proper back posture. Improved fitness will lead to a better ability to participate in physical activities.

It's best to start off with a trained physical therapist who can teach the exercises and monitor activity level so that it increases gradually. Once the program has been learned, people often find that the physical therapist is no longer necessary.

 
Anticonvulsants
(Neurontin/gabapentin, Tegretol/carbamazepine, Lyrica/pregabalin, others)
 

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Anticonvulsants (anti-seizure medications) can improve some types of chronic nerve pain. Sometimes anticonvulsants are used in combination with antidepressants for treating chronic back pain (back pain for more than 6 weeks) when nerve pain is also present (pain that shoots down the leg to the ankle).
Tell Me More...
  Close

Anticonvulsants

Side effects may include sleepiness, dizziness, and fatigue, but these symptoms often resolve within 2 weeks. Gabapentin (Neurontin) is considered the 'first choice' anticonvulsant and Carbamazepine (Tegretol) the 'second choice' drug.

 
Anti-inflammatory drugs
(Motrin or Advil/ibuprofen, Aleve/naproxen, more)
 

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Anti-inflammatory drugs are frequently prescribed to control pain. Careful monitoring for side effects is necessary.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Anti-inflammatory drugs

Guidelines/experts suggest that anti-inflammatory medications (Motrin, ibuprofen, Advil, naproxen, Aleve, more) be used to manage low back pain. These drugs can cause significant side effects, however, such as stomach pain and bleeding ulcers especially when taken daily and should be used with caution, particularly in older individuals who are much more susceptible to developing side effects. Taking them with milk or food, and taking the lowest effective dose tend to help avoid these stomach problems.

These drugs should generally not be used in those who have kidney problems or are pregnant. People with high blood pressure or diabetes may not be able to take anti-inflammatory drugs.

A newer category of anti-inflammatory drugs, called the COX-2 inhibitors (Celebrex, others) can be used in individuals at higher risk for stomach problems, but have side effects of their own, including slightly increased risk of stroke and/or heart attack; they are expensive and only available with a prescription. They are only useful in a small group of people with back pain. Vioxx (rofecoxib), one of the COX-2 inhibitors was taken off of the market recently because of serious heart-related side effects and stroke.

 
Antidepressants
(Elavil/amitriptyline, others)
 

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Antidepressants are sometimes used for treatment of chronic pain, usually at lower doses than are used for treating depression.

Chronic back pain due to nerve irritation (a "pinched nerve" with pain running down the leg, numbness or weakness) may be particularly responsive to these drugs in certain individuals.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Antidepressants

Use of antidepressants for chronic pain may reduce or eliminate the need for antii-nflammatories (Motrin, ibuprofen, Aleve, naproxen, more) or sedatives (sleeping pills). There is evidence that older (tricyclic) antidepressant pills may be more effective than newer SSRIs (Prozac, others) for chronic pain. People who take them should be monitored for side effects which include dry mouth, sleepiness, weight gain, stomach disturbances, and impotence. Major depression associated with low back pain should be treated by a mental health practitioner.

 
Psychosocial Interventions/Education  

Not available 
 
 
 
 
Delayed recovery of low back pain may be due to non-medical factors such as fear, anxiety, depression, interpersonal relationship issues, and work issues. These factors should be evaluated by a practitioner familiar with chronic pain issues.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Psychosocial Interventions/Education

Interventions include individual or family counseling, stress management/relaxation techniques/biofeedback, and psychological crisis intervention.

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Chronic Pain - Not Recommended
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Muscle Relaxants
(Flexeril/cyclobenzaprine, Soma/carisoprodol, Robaxin/methocarbamol, Valium/diazepam, many others)
 

Poor 
 
 
 
 
Muscle relaxants act on the brain rather than on muscle directly. They are sometimes prescribed in combination with other medicines for acute (early phase) low back pain, but are not used to treat chronic (longstanding) conditions.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Muscle Relaxants

Because there is little or no evidence of their effectiveness in chronic low back pain, and because of their extensive list of side effects (mental confusion, depression, possible addiction or dependance, more) they generally are not recommended.

 
Sedatives (Sleeping pills)  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Not recommended. Can be addictive. Better choices available.

Inability to sleep due to pain is better managed using other medications that treat the pain directly. Occasionally, individuals may not respond to these medications and mild sleeping medication may be used for a short time.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Sedatives (Sleeping pills)

A type of antidepressant (tricyclic anti-depressants such as Elavil/amitryptiline or Desyrel/trazodone) are better choices to treat sleep disturbance due to pain, because they also help treat the pain directly and are not addictive.

 
Steroid Pills  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Not effective. Steroid pills are not recommended for the treatment of low back pain. Serious side effects.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Steroid Pills

Steroid pills have not shown any benefit over safer drugs and can cause many serious side effects.

 
Spinal Manipulation
(Chiropractic treatment)
 

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
May provide some benefit for certain people. Because of high cost and small benefit, not recommended by national guidelines for chronic (longlasting) back pain.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Spinal Manipulation

Studies show that chiropractic manipulation is only slightly better than placebo ("fake" treatment) for chronic low back pain (back pain for more than 6 weeks). National guidelines do not recommend chiropractic manipulation for this condition.

 
Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation
("TENS" unit)
 

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
A device that delivers a small electrical stimulation to the back muscles. No evidence to date of effectiveness.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation

With TENS treatment, a small electrical stimulation is delivered to the muscles of the low back, in theory, for the purpose of decreasing pain.

There is insufficient study evidence to recommend TENS alone for the treatment of chronic low back pain (back pain for more than 6 weeks).

Although TENS is often used for chronic back pain, there is little research to support this practice.

 
Acupuncture  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Although acupuncture is often used for chronic back pain there is little research to support this practice.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Acupuncture

There insufficient evidence from medical studies to show definitively whether acupuncture is useful for chronic low back pain.

Additional, well-designed studies are needed for definitive recommendations.

 
Narcotic medication  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
These medications do not treat the underlying cause of chronic pain and should be avoided if at all possible. In the rare case when narcotics are used for people with severe chronic pain, their use must be monitored by a specialist in chronic pain conditions.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Narcotic medication

Guidelines/experts recommend against the use of narcotics for chronic pain. Concerns about side effects such as drowsiness or depression and addiction to narcotics are issues when using these drugs long-term. If these drugs are used they should be limited to a brief period of time.

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Chronic Pain - Special Situations
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Epidural Steroid Injection  

Good 
 
 
 
 
Epidural steroid injections may be useful for people with nerve pain/sciatica (pain that shoots down the leg to the ankle). These injections are not helpful in those whose pain is only located in the back and not the leg. Should be performed by an experienced physician.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Epidural Steroid Injection

In this procedure, a steroid medication is injected into the back near the nerve that is being pinched or irritated. Studies have shown that steroid injections improve shooting nerve pain (from a pinched nerve). The injection is relatively safe with few minor potential complications if performed by a specialist trained in the technique.

More...
Back pain that travels down the leg is known as a "pinched" nerve (sciatica). A "pinched" nerve (sciatica) is most commonly caused by pressure from a disc (or cushion) that sits between the bones of the spine. The disc can bulge out of place (a "herniated disc"), or a piece can break off and press on a nearby nerve.

In most cases, a pinched nerve (sciatica) gets better without further treatment after a period of rest.

Telling the difference between a simple back strain and a pinched nerve can be difficult . There are several clues that help your doctor tell them apart:

  • Pain from a pinched nerve usually travels below the knee (often down to the ankle) in very specific patterns, whereas pain from a muscle strain can travel to the upper leg but does not usually go below the knee
  • Pain and numbness from a pinched nerve is usually located in the specific part of the leg that the nerve runs along. The route that the affected nerve travels determines where the symptoms are felt. The exact path of a particular nerve can vary somewhat from individual to individual, but your doctor can get a pretty good sense, based on the location of your symptoms, whether or not the pattern suggests a pinched nerve
  • Typically, pain due to a pinched nerve travels to the lower leg in a narrow band that feels more like it is on the surface than deep in the leg. The pain from muscle sprains/strains is usually felt more deeply and in a wider band.

Diagnostic tests such as MRIs are helpful, but not conclusive in telling the two conditions apart. Studies have demonstrated that MRIs show herniated disc in 50% of healthy people without back symptoms. Just because a bulging disc is present on an MRI does not mean that it's the cause of the back pain. The diagnosis is generally made only when both symptoms and the MRI a consistent with a disc herniation.

With a herniated disc, the disc or "cushion" that sits between the bones of the spine develops a weakness/tear and begins to bulge. The bulging disc pinches the nerves of the spine as they travel to the legs (where they control sensation and movement). When a nerve is pinched, it can cause pain, numbness, or tingling in the legs. A back sprain/strain can also cause these leg symptoms but in different locations.

The reason it is important to tell a pinched nerve from simple muscle strain is that the two conditions are usually treated differently. For example, muscle strains are not generally treated with surgery, whereas a pinched nerve may be, usually as a last resort.

In summary, both muscle sprains and pinched nerves can cause pain, numbness, tingling, and loss of feeling in the leg - just in different locations. Pinched nerves can also cause muscle weakness in the legs, while simple muscle strains cannot.

If you have any doubts about your diagnosis, you may wish to get a second opinion from a back specialist (such as an orthopedist who specializes in low back problems).

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Chronic Pain - Insufficient Data
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Trigger Point Injections  

Not available 
 
 
 
 
Injection of steroids into the back muscles. Limited information about effectiveness. May be considered for those whose back pain appears to be due to muscle tightness or irritation of "trigger points".
Tell Me More...
  Close

Trigger Point Injections

With this procedure, steroids are injected into a muscle in the back. Some experts believe that they may provide some relief for people who seem to have muscle tightness in a particular location ("trigger point") in the back, but have not been found to be useful for those who do not have specific "trigger points". There have been no high quality clinical studies of "trigger point" injections.

 

 
     
NOTE: Just because a drug or combination of drugs can cause a symptom does not mean it is actually causing your symptom. Symptoms can be caused by medical conditions as well. Make sure that your physician is aware of any symptoms you are experiencing so he/she can work with you to determine the cause. Please DO NOT STOP MEDICATIONS without first consulting a physician since doing so could be hazardous to your health.
DISCLAIMER: Please note that the information DoubleCheckMD.com provides is intended to help individuals to work with their medical professionals and is for educational purposes only. It does not constitute medical or healthcare advice and serves to supplement, not substitute for, the expertise and judgment of a healthcare professional. In all cases individuals should consult with a physician before taking any action based on DoubleCheckMD feedback including, but not limited to ceasing taking any drug, changing diet or commencing or discontinuing any course of treatment. The information provided by DoubleCheckMD.com is not intended to cover all possible uses, directions, precautions, drug interactions or adverse effects, nor should it be construed to indicate that the use of a particular drug is safe, appropriate or effective.


 
 
Username
Password
 
Forgot Password Log into DoubleCheckMD
 
 
 
Email Address
 
 
 
 
 
 
We'll keep Your Personal Information Private

Registration helps ensure the privacy of your personal health information. It's easy to register. Just enter a username and password. This is information you will use to login so you may want to write it down.
Username*
Password*
Password* (verify)
First Name (optional)
Last Name (optional)
Email Address (optional)
I have read and agree to abide by the DoubleCheckMD Terms of Use and DoubleCheckMD Privacy Policy.
I am a medical professional
 
Register
 
 
First name
Last name
Email Address
Comments*
 
 
 
First name
Last name
Email Address
Comments*
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Close
HOLDER
 
 
Close
HOLDER
 
     
 
 
     
     
 
Close
HOLDER