My Drugs & SymptomsDrugsDrugs By ConditionTreatments
  Drug Search

   
 
Asthma in Adults quick look
This chart rates treatment options according to general effectiveness, ease of use, side effects and safety.
Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
First Choice
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Eliminating Asthma Triggers (Allergens and Irritants)  

Very good 
 
 
 
 
Most effective and safest approach available for people with allergy-related asthma. Some evidence to suggest that avoiding exposure to certain allergy-causing substances may protect lung function over the long-term.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Eliminating Asthma Triggers (Allergens and Irritants)

Eliminating exposure to allergic and environmental irritants has proven to be the most successful way to treat people with allergy-induced asthma. Studies have shown that exposure to allergens (e.g. house dust, mites, animal dander, cockroaches, etc.) can cause increased inflammation in the lungs, worsening asthma symptoms, decreased lung function, and an increased need for asthma medications.

Avoiding these allergens reduces asthma symptoms significantly and decreases lung inflammation. Measures such as removing animals from the home, minimizing exposure to allergy-causing dust mites, eliminating cigarette smoking in the home, exterminating cockroaches, etc. can be highly beneficial.

If doubt exists about which substances are triggering allergic reactions, allergy testing can be performed.

 
Cessation of Smoking  

Very good 
 
 
 
 
Smoking is a common asthma trigger and should be avoided. Smoking causes airway inflammation, swelling and irritation and increases the likelihood of asthma flares.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Cessation of Smoking

Studies have shown that children with asthma who are exposed to cigarette smoke have more asthma symptoms, and require more frequent emergency room visits for their asthma.

 
Avoiding Asthma Triggers  

Very good 
 
 
 
 
Avoiding asthma triggers is a very important aspect of asthma treatment. Continued exposure to allergens can cause serious asthma attacks even in people who are taking powerful asthma medications.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Avoiding Asthma Triggers

Avoiding substances that trigger asthma (for some people this might include animals/pets, cigarette smoke, chemical exposures, pollen, etc.) is very important for asthma control. Asthma triggers cause the airways to constrict or close-down so that air cannot get through. They also cause irritation and swelling in the airways which makes the airways more sensitive and irritable for the next few hours to days and more likely to constrict.

 
Inhaled, Quick-Acting Beta 2 Drugs
(Ventolin/albuterol, Proventil/albuterol, Maxair/pirbuterol, Alupent/metaproterenol, Metaprel/metaproterenol, Brethine/terbutaline)
 

Good 
 
 
 
 
First choice for asthma flares. Powerful. Fast-acting - can be used for immediate relief. A mainstay of asthma treatment.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Inhaled, Quick-Acting Beta 2 Drugs

Inhaled beta 2 drugs provide quick relief (within 2-3 minutes) and are approximately four times more powerful than other types of asthma drugs. They are the drug of choice for asthma flares and for those with infrequent symptoms who need occasional, quick-acting treatment. They are also the drug of choice for emergency asthma attacks.

Unlike older beta drugs (epinephrine, isoproterenol, and isoetharine), the newer beta 2 drugs have few effects on the heart except at high doses. Beta 2 drugs should be administered at the lowest possible dose at which symptoms are controlled.

The effects of beta 2-drugs last from 4 to 6 hours; considerably longer than comparable medications.

Beta 2 drugs work by opening up the airways allowing air to flow more readily.

Common side effects can include heart pounding, jitteriness, and shakiness.

 
Inhaled Steroids
(Flovent/fluticasone, Pulmicort/budesonide, QVAR or Beclovent or Vanceril/all are betamethasone, Azmacort/triamcinolone, Aerobid/flunisolide)
 

Good 
 
 
 
 
Powerful. Highly effective in preventing asthma attacks. Used daily for prevention; not used for flares. Added to asthma treatment when quick-acting (beta 2) drugs, alone, do not control symptoms.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Inhaled Steroids

Inhaled steroids are powerful drugs that are highly effective in reducing lung inflammation and in preventing asthma attacks. They are often used for people whose symptoms are not adequately controlled with quick-acting beta 2 drugs alone.

Inhaled steroids cause few side effects except when taken at higher doses.

It is important to note that inhaled steroids take up to a week or more to work and, therefore, should not be relied upon alone to treat acute flairs of asthma symptoms.

Most common side effects include dry, irritated throat and yeast infection in the mouth or throat.

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Other Options
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Mast Cell Stabilizers
(Intal/cromolyn)
 

Good 
 
 
 
 
Used daily for prevention; not used for asthma flares since they are not fast-acting. Moderately effective. An alternative to inhaled steroids to prevent asthma flares. Sometimes used to prevent exercise-related asthma.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Mast Cell Stabilizers

Mast cell stabilizers are occasionally used instead of inhaled steroids especially for children although they are not as effective and do not prevent severe attacks as well as inhaled steroids. They must be taken 4 times a day. Their main appeal is that they cause almost no side effects.

They are also sometimes used as an alternative to beta 2 drugs to prevent exercise-induced asthma (taken 15-20 minutes before beginning exercise). They are not quick-acting and, therefore, not effective once symptoms flare.

 
Long-Acting Beta Drugs
(Serevent/salmeterol, Foradil/formoterol, Advair Diskus/salmeterol-fluticasone)
 

Good 
 
 
 
 
Used daily for prevention; not used for flares. Effects last for 12 hours. Minimal side effects. Often used along with inhaled steroids for asthma that is difficult to control. Not fast-acting and, therefore, not effective for asthma flares.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Long-Acting Beta Drugs

Salmeterol and Foradil are long-acting forms of the beta 2 drugs. These medications may be used to treat people whose symptoms are not entirely relieved with the combinations of a short-acting beta 2 drug and inhaled steroids. They are also used to treat people who have exercise-induced asthma.

Because they are long-acting, these drugs are useful for people with night-time flares who would otherwise have to awaken to treat symptoms.

Although long-acting, they are not fast-acting (takes 20-30 minutes) and, therefore, not useful for the acute flare.

Usually taken twice daily but some people do well with once daily.

Important to note that the long-acting beta drugs do not have any effect on lung inflammation and are not recommended as the sole asthma treatment. They should be used along with inhaled steroids or other anti-inflammatory asthma drugs.

Side effects may include jitteriness, tremors, racing heart, and muscle cramps.

Advair Discus combines the inhaled steroid - fluticasone (Flovent) with the long-acting beta drug - Salmeterol (Serevent) which can be convenient for some individuals who take both drugs.

 
Leukotriene Drugs
(Accolate/zafirlukast, Singulair/montelukast, Zyflo/zileuton)
 

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Used daily for prevention; not used for flares. Modest effectiveness. An alternative to long-acting beta drugs for asthma prevention for people with mild asthma. May be particularly useful for aspirin related asthma.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Leukotriene Drugs

Leukotriene drugs are unpredictable and work in less than 50% of people with asthma. It takes about a month to determine whether these medications will work for a particular person.

Zafirlukast and montelukast are longer-acting than zileuton and can be taken once or twice a day.

Leukotriene drugs are used for symptom prevention rather than for relief during acute attacks.

They can cause liver inflammation and liver blood tests should be monitored when taking the drugs.

 
Theophylline
(Theo-Dur, Slo-Phyllin, Slo-Bid, Theo-24, Uniphyl, Uni-Dur, Theolair, Elixophyllin)
 

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Used daily for prevention; not used for flares. Moderately effective. Not often prescribed - mostly replaced by long-acting beta drugs. Theophylline blood levels must be checked regularly. Interactions with other drugs are common. Not quick-acting; not useful for asthma flares.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Theophylline

Theophylline is moderately effective in decreasing lung inflammation and in preventing asthma flares. It is not as effective as long-acting beta 2 drugs. Before beta 2 drugs, theophylline used to be the standard asthma treatment but has largely been replaced by long-acting beta drugs. It is an alternative for people who cannot take long-acting beta 2 drugs.

Theophylline pills are usually taken once or twice a day.

When taking theophylline, it is important to have blood tests to periodically monitor theophylline blood levels since high blood level cause a risk of seizures and serious abnormalities of the heart rhythm. Theophylline overdose can even cause fatalities.

A number of other drugs can increase theophylline blood levels including cimetadine (Tagamet), propranalol (Inderal), phenytoin (Dilantin), certain antibiotics and several other less common medications. Cigarettes and marijuana will also cause theophylline levels to rise. In addition, certain conditions such as liver disease, heart failure, particular lung conditions, and advanced age tend to increase theophylline levels.

Common side effects include nervousness, nausea, vomiting, loss of appetite, diarrhea and headache.

 
Oral steroids  

Poor 
 
 
 
 
Highly potent but can cause serious side effects with long-term use. Reserved for those whose symptoms do not respond to other treatments or for severe asthma attacks.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Oral steroids

Steroid pills are the most powerful asthma medication available. Short courses of steroid pills are often used to treat severe asthma attacks. A small percentage of people require long-term steroid pills for severe asthma that does not improve with other medications.

Chronic use of steroid pills can cause a number of serious side effects, such as bone loss, fluid retention, etc. Long-term use is less often necessary now because of the availability of inhaled steroids which are nearly as effective and which cause far fewer complications.

It is important to note that, for those who have taken steroid pills for approximately three weeks or more, steroids should not be stopped abruptly since this often results in an asthma attack or other serious problem.

Steroids in the pill (and intravenous) form take up to six hours to work and, therefore, should not be relied upon alone to treat the acute asthma attack.

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Not Recommended
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Quick-Acting Beta 2 Drugs in Pill or Liquid Form  

Poor 
 
 
 
 
Not as effective as inhalers. Cause more side effects.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Quick-Acting Beta 2 Drugs in Pill or Liquid Form

Beta 2 drugs are available in liquid and pill form but are not as effective as inhalers. They also take longer to work (20-30 minutes) and cause more jitteriness than the inhaled form of the drug.

The liquid form or pill form might be used occasionally for very young children and others who are unable to inhale medication.

 
Over-the-Counter Inhalers
(Epinephrine, Primatene Mist)
 

Poor 
 
 
 
 
Not recommended. Less effective, shorter acting, and more side effects compared to prescription inhalers.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Over-the-Counter Inhalers

Use of over-the-counter inhalers for asthma flares can result in serious problems. These medications are not effective in decreasing the lung inflammation and swelling that can occur with asthma. If inflammation becomes severe and is left untreated, serious and even life-threatening breathing problems may occur.

 
Catecholamines
(Isuprel, isoproterenol, Isoetharine)
 

Poor 
 
 
 
 
Not recommended. Less effective, shorter acting, and more side effects compared to newer beta 2 drugs.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Catecholamines

Catecholamines belong to the same group of drugs as the beta 2 drugs. Catecholamines, however, place considerable stress on the heart, and are effective for only a short period of time - only 30 to 90 min. The beta 2 drugs have effectively replaced catecholamines since they are as effective, longer-acting and have virtually no impact on the heart.

Isoprotetenol is the most potent of the catecholamines.

Isoetharine has the least impact on the heart of the catecholamines but is not very effective in treating asthma.

 
Long-Acting Beta Drugs in Pill Form
(Volmax, VoSpire ER/long-acting albuterol)
 

Poor 
 
 
 
 
Not as effective as inhalers. Cause more side effects. Inconvenient.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Long-Acting Beta Drugs in Pill Form

The long-acting beta drugs in the pill form are not as effective as the inhaled form of the drugs. Also, the pills may cause more intense side effects of jitteriness, heart pounding, and tremors than the inhaled long-acting beta drugs.

The pills are inconvenient - they must be taken three time a day.

 
Expectorants and Cough Syrups
(Robitussin, more)
 

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Often used. No evidence of any benefit in people with asthma.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Expectorants and Cough Syrups

Expectorants are drugs that help break up mucus by causing fluids to be secreted into the airways. One expectorant called acetylcysteine may actually worsen asthma symptoms in certain individuals. This problem can be prevented by using acetylcysteine in combination with inhaled beta - drugs.

 
Sedatives and Tranquilizers  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
WARNING. Do not use these drugs during asthma attacks. Cessation of breathing can result.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Sedatives and Tranquilizers

Sedatives and tranquilizers should never be taken during the acute asthma attack, even in the face of great anxiety. They decrease the ability to breath and can cause a life-threatening situation. These drugs have been known to cause a complete cessation of breathing during asthma attacks.

 
Methotrexate and Gold Salts  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Minimal effectiveness. Serious side effects.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Methotrexate and Gold Salts

Theories have been proposed to suggest that methotrexate and gold treatments might be helpful for people whose asthma is severe enough to require long-term oral steroid pills. However, methotrexate and gold seem to be minimally effective for asthma and cause numerous and serious side effects. Treatment with these substances is considered experimental.

 
Intravenous Magnesium  

Very poor 
 
 
 
 
Controversy about effectiveness for acute asthma attacks.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Intravenous Magnesium

There is controversy about the effectiveness of IV magnesium for acute asthma attacks and its use is not currently recommended.

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Special Situations
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
New Short-Acting Beta 2 Drug
(Xopenex/levalbuterol)
 

Good 
 
 
 
 
High cost, new inhaled beta 2 drug that causes fewer side effects. For asthma flares.
Tell Me More...
  Close

New Short-Acting Beta 2 Drug

New inhaled, short-acting beta 2 drug that causes slightly less jitteriness and heart racing than the standard beta 2 drugs. May be recommended for older people with heart disease or young children who become very jittery from other inhaled beta 2 drugs. Side effects are only slightly better than with other beta 2 drugs and the slight improvement is probably not worth the much higher cost for most people.

 
Anticholinergics
(Atrovent/ipratropium, DuoNeb or Combivent; both are albuterol/ipratropium)
 

Fair 
 
 
 
 
Used daily for prevention; not used for flares. Mostly used for people who have lung conditions called emphysema or chronic bronchitis. Modest potency; slow acting (10-15 minutes). Sometimes used for those who can't take beta 2 drugs.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Anticholinergics

Anticholinergics are not recommended as a first choice for asthma since they are not as effective as the beta 2 drugs and they are slower acting (10-15 verses 1-2 minutes). (Some sources report that anticholinergics take up to 60 to 90 minutes to work).

Anticholinergics may be prescribed for people with asthma in two situations; for those with serious heart disease who cannot risk the heart stimulation caused by beta 2 drugs; and for those who are taking a type of antidepressent called an MAO inhibitor (Nardil, Parnate) or an anti-Parkinson drug called Eldepryl (selegiline). Some physicians will also prescribe anticholinergics when asthma symptoms persist despite the use of beta 2 drugs.

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Emerging Therapies
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
New Inhaled Steroids
(Asmanex/mometasone, Nasonex/mometasone, Omnaris/ciclesonide)
 

Good 
 
 
 
 
New inhaled steroid medications.
Tell Me More...
  Close

New Inhaled Steroids

Asmanex is available in other countries and is available in the United States as a nasal steroid spray called Nasonex. It is effective when taken once daily.

Another new inhaled steroid under development, called ciclesonide, is activated in the lungs only alter it is inhaled. This drug may cause fewer side effects than other inhaled steroids. It is also taken once daily.

 
New Longer-acting beta 2 drugs
(Foradil/formoterol)
 

Good 
 
 
 
 
A purified form of an existing long-acting beta 2 drug called Foradil. Hoped to be more effective and longer-lasting.
Tell Me More...
  Close

New Longer-acting beta 2 drugs

May act immediately and last up to 24 hours - twice as long as existing long-acting beta drugs.

 
New Combination Inhalers
(Symbicort/budesonide-formoterol)
 

Good 
 
 
 
 
A new combination inhaler with an inhaled steroid and a long acting beta drug.
Tell Me More...
  Close

New Combination Inhalers

Combines the inhaled steroid budesonide (Pulmicort) with the long-acting beta drug formoterol (Foradil).

 
New Anti-IgE Therapy
(Xolair/omalizumab)
 

Good 
 
 
 
 
A new medication that may treat the most severe forms of allergy-related asthma and decrease the need for steroid pills.
Tell Me More...
  Close

New Anti-IgE Therapy

Decreases a substance called IgE, which is a molecule that is involved in the allergic response. Studies show that people with the most severe forms of allergic asthma may experience great improvement with this drug and may be able to decrease their dependence on the use of steroid pills and therefore, avoid the serious side effects that steroid pills can cause when used chronically.

Anti-IgE drugs are administered by injection.

 
New Theophylline-Like Drugs
(Ariflo)
 

Fair 
 
 
 
 
New theophylline-like drugs that cause fewer side effects than theophylline.
Tell Me More...
  Close

New Theophylline-Like Drugs

Several drugs of this type are under investigation. The hope is to create a drug that acts like theophylline but causes fewer side effects such as nausea and heart pounding, and interacts with fewer drugs than theophylline. None of these drugs have reached the market yet. Ariflo is still pending FDA approval.

 

Legend:     Excellent  Very Good  Good  Fair  Poor  Not available 
Insufficient Data
Treatment Overall Score Effective-
ness
Safety Ease
of Use
Side
Effects
Comments
Allergy Shots - Desensitization  

Poor 
 
 
 
 
Widely used. Effectiveness unproven. Few reliable scientific studies.
Tell Me More...
  Close

Allergy Shots - Desensitization

Allergy shots are commonly used to treat people with allergy-related asthma. Few sound scientific studies have evaluated the effectiveness of allergy shots, but those that have been attempted have failed to find any significant asthma improvement.

 

 
     
NOTE: Just because a drug or combination of drugs can cause a symptom does not mean it is actually causing your symptom. Symptoms can be caused by medical conditions as well. Make sure that your physician is aware of any symptoms you are experiencing so he/she can work with you to determine the cause. Please DO NOT STOP MEDICATIONS without first consulting a physician since doing so could be hazardous to your health.
DISCLAIMER: Please note that the information DoubleCheckMD.com provides is intended to help individuals to work with their medical professionals and is for educational purposes only. It does not constitute medical or healthcare advice and serves to supplement, not substitute for, the expertise and judgment of a healthcare professional. In all cases individuals should consult with a physician before taking any action based on DoubleCheckMD feedback including, but not limited to ceasing taking any drug, changing diet or commencing or discontinuing any course of treatment. The information provided by DoubleCheckMD.com is not intended to cover all possible uses, directions, precautions, drug interactions or adverse effects, nor should it be construed to indicate that the use of a particular drug is safe, appropriate or effective.


 
 
Username
Password
 
Forgot Password Log into DoubleCheckMD
 
 
 
Email Address
 
 
 
 
 
 
We'll keep Your Personal Information Private

Registration helps ensure the privacy of your personal health information. It's easy to register. Just enter a username and password. This is information you will use to login so you may want to write it down.
Username*
Password*
Password* (verify)
First Name (optional)
Last Name (optional)
Email Address (optional)
I have read and agree to abide by the DoubleCheckMD Terms of Use and DoubleCheckMD Privacy Policy.
I am a medical professional
 
Register
 
 
First name
Last name
Email Address
Comments*
 
 
 
First name
Last name
Email Address
Comments*
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Close
HOLDER
 
 
Close
HOLDER
 
     
 
 
     
     
 
Close
HOLDER